Skip to main content
European Commission
Knowledge4Policy (K4P)

BLUE2 for D5

By simulating the impacts of policy measures focused on minimization of human-induced eutrophication across different regions and timeframes, Blue2 helps identify the most effective approaches to managing marine resources sustainably.

  • Projects and activities | Last updated: 29 Oct 2026

How the models can help

Numerical models such as Blue2 can be useful for filling in data gaps and making inferences beyond observed conditions. In particular, numerical tools can provide valuable information to assess and combat eutrophication by:

  • Tracking Nutrient Budgets
  • Predicting Algal Bloom Dynamics
  • Mapping Hypoxia and "Dead Zones"
  • Testing Management Scenarios

How the models work

Numerical eutrophication models work by coupling hydrodynamics (how water moves) with biogeochemistry (how nutrients and biology interact). They solve sets of mathematical equations across a digital grid representing the water body. The model development  process includes:

  • Setting up the digital grid - physical boundaries and resolution

  • Setting up the hydrodynamic conditions - meteorological forcing, tides and river discharge

  • Setting up the biogeochemical kinetics - nutrient uptake, grazing, mortality and settling, and mineralization

  • model calibration, sensitivity analysis and validation

The calculation of currents and mixing is directly linked to the calculation of nutrient and biomass transport, as well as growth and decay processes.

By developing and applying a dedicated BLUE2, we aim to characterise eutrophication and associated mechanisms, using:

  • Classical model-based D5 indicators: Track nutrient concentrations, water column chlorophyll-a, transparency, and dissolved oxygen.

  • Generalised model-based eutrophication index: Apply Trophic Transfer Index (TTI) and trophic-web models from primary producers to top predators.

We assess how environmental change affects eutrophication and marine ecosystems, with a particular focus on:

  • Policy-driven nutrient reductions: Simulate inland water management changes (e.g., Urban Waste Water and Nitrates Directives) on coastal marine zones.
  • Climate change: Perform long-term simulations to show whether it worsens or improves environmental conditions in EU basins.

Scientific work

Effects of Nutrient Management Scenarios on Marine Eutrophication Indicators: A Pan-European, Multi-Model Assessment in Support of the MSFD.

For each sea region, up to five coupled biogeochemical models from institutes all over Europe were brought together for the first time. A multi-model ensemble approach was followed in which different marine models for the diverse EU basins were fed with common rivers' load scenarios based on a set of pre-defined pressures at continental level. 
Models were involved in the exercise to increase confidence in the results and to assess the uncertainty associated to model structure and deficiencies. 
General and basin specific conclusions on the impacts of the freshwater scenarios on descriptors associated to the MSFD were drawn from the different simulations.

eu
(A) Ensemble means and model-specific relative change at load reduction scenario (compared to reference scenario) for the MSFD regions of nitrate (MSFD indicator D5C1). (B) Consistency map showing, if all or at least most models have the same trend of the relative change at load reduction scenario (compared to reference scenario) with respect to nitrate (MSFD indicator D5C1). (C) Share of the total area (bold bars) and of the shelf region (dotted bar), where all or most models show consistent changes with respect to nitrate (MSFD indicator D5C1).

A novel pan-European marine model ensemble was established (Friedland et al., 2021), covering nearly all seas under the regulation of the MSFD, with the aim of providing a consistent assessment of the potential impacts of riverine nutrient reduction scenarios on marine eutrophication indicators. 

The major role of riverine outflows in shaping the current and future habitats of Harmful Algal Blooms (HABs): the case of the North Sea.

The extension of the potential habitat of HABs in the North Sea using observational data and model experiments under current and future climate scenarios is studied. HABs develop under specific conditions, such as very low or very high Dissolved Inorganic Nitrogen / Dissolved Inorganic Phosphorus ratio (DIN:DIP ratio), low salinity and high temperature.

Climate change projections indicate a decrease in salinity concomitant with an increase in surface temperature, and increase in DIN:DIP ratio, potentially leading to an offshore extension of HAB habitat.

Reducing nitrogen and phosphorus loads originating from rivers would affect both dissolved inorganic nitrogen (DIN) and phosphorus (DIP) levels with DIN being more sensitive to load reduction, thereby constraining HAB habitat extension, as shown by 16 sensitivity experiments to load reductions.

eu
(a) - fraction of the year when the HAB favorable nutrient criterion (DIN : DIP ratio > 48) is fulfilled in the reference BLUE2 GETM experiment. b–p: difference between 16 riverine nutrients reductions experiments and the reference. NxPy – x.y indicate the remaining percentage of total nitrogen or total phosphorus compared to the reference experiment.

The study (Duteil et al., 2024)  underscores the importance of considering both physical and biogeochemical factors in assessing HAB habitat dynamics and the potential impacts of climate change and nutrient reduction measures on HAB expansion in the North Sea.

Integrated Nutrient Criteria for Controlling Eutrophication and the Proliferation of Harmful Phytoplankton in the Black Sea Based on Scenario Analysis.
eu
Average percentage changes with the bootstrap 95% intervals (lines) in (a) DIN, (b) DIP, and (c) Chla within the combined 2nm coastal zone of Bulgaria and Romania, based on 16 scenario simulations in 2010-2022 period. Average changes are calculated for 2018-2022 period.

The model results indicate that a 20% reduction in both N and P from EU rivers would result in about 24% decrease in N within the Bulgarian and Romanian 2nm coastal waters, whilst sustaining the N:P ratio across various spatial scales—from river inputs to coastal and off-shore zones (Miladinova et al., 2026). 

Regional sensitivity of European Marine Eutrophication Indicators to Progressive Reductions in Riverine Nutrient Loads.

We use the BLUE2 framework, a pan European numerical ocean circulation and biogeochemistry modelling framework, to examine how progressive reductions in riverine nitrogen and phosphorus affect surface nutrients and chlorophyll across major European marine regions (Duteil, O., Macias, D., Ferreira-Cordeiro, N. Garcia-Gorriz,E., Miladinova S.,Parn, O., Azevedo, A., Polimene, L., Stip A. European marine indicators show regional sensitivity to progressive reductions in riverine nutrient loads, Comm. Sustain. (accepted)).

We analyse sixteen model experiments per basin, representing different combinations of total nitrogen (TN) and total phosphorus (TP) load reductions over the period 2010 to 2015. The results show substantial regional differences in both the magnitude and the sign of ecosystem responses. In some regions, chlorophyll responds mainly to reductions in nitrogen, while in others phosphorus reductions are more influential, and several marine systems respond to reductions in both nutrients.

eu
Regions where changes in TN (TP) explain at least 70% of the total chlorophyll variance are shown in blue (red). The regions where both changes in TN and TP explain at least 40% of the variance are shown in green.
eu
Impact of total nitrogen (TN) and total phosphorus (TP) load reduction on surface CHL (% change) compared to the reference experiment for the different MSFD subregions (BAL: Baltic Sea – GNS: Greater North Sea – CS: Celtic Sea - BoBIC: Bay of Biscay and Iberian coast– BLK: Black Sea – WM / CM / EM: Western / Central / Eastern Mediterranean Sea – ADR: Adriatic Sea)

The analysis identifies where reductions in nitrogen, phosphorus, or both are most effective, supporting the definition of region specific nutrient reduction targets under European marine policies.

Lessons Learned

  • Inorganic pools react fast to policy cuts, while chlorophyll-a and bottom-water oxygen lag due to internal recycling and sediment release. Remineralization in deep water sustains oxygen demand even when external loads fall.
  • The magnitude and the direction of the response to nutrient reductions is highly variable among European marine basins.
  • Reductions in one nutrient can cause localized imbalances in non-limiting nutrients depending on regional conditions. 
Privacy statements, terms and conditions.
You will be directed to the EU Login website where you can login/register as a user. Once connected, your credentials (First name, last name, username, email) will be registered in Knowledge4policy as part of your profile, which will allow you to get involved in all Knowledge4policy communities (help is available).

You are about to navigate to an external website. Please note that we are not responsible for its content.